In honor of the holidays, I made a student cry today. I say it's not my fault. You tell me if you think otherwise.
This is Finals Week at my school. And just to reiterate for newcomers -- this is college. I have a nice, streamlined system for collecting final papers from students: I sit in the linoleum paradise of my office, and students have a three-hour window to stop by and turn stuff in. They hand the essays over, I praise them for their outstanding ability to meet a deadline, they lie and say our class was the best one ever!, and I wish them luck in their future endeavors. Then they scramble to get out the door and begin the process of wiping our class from their memory banks. Probably with a quick succession of jager bombs.
So I'm sitting in my office today, collecting papers, watching the clock. Everyone has until noon. I've told students about today's deadline weeks ahead of time: "I'm leaving at noon. Don't be late. This paper is worth 25% of your grade. Don't be late. I won't be checking my email later. I won't accept anything late. Don't be late. I'm hardcore about deadlines and you know it. Remember The Usual Suspects?" I say to them. "Remember Keyser Soze, the guy who disappears without a trace? At noon on the 15th, I'm gonna Keyser Soze my ass outta here, and not reappear until Spring Semester."
It's a whole speech. I give it every year, and at this point it's honed to perfection.
Here's the thing: One student always blows it. Inevitably, one student always misses the deadline and takes a zero on the last paper. Every semester, I predict who it might be. Sometimes I'm right, sometimes I'm not.
This year, I predicted it would be Joey McFakeName.
Joey is a good guy. He's smart. He's a good writer. Joey McFakeName's main problem this semester has been procrastination. He was late to class a lot, missed deadlines, failed to follow instructions, etc. Yet he was great in discussions. Yet he showed an enthusiasm for everything we talked about in class. Yet he wore a cool fedora.
At 11:57 this morning, I look at my watch and realize I haven't seen Joey. Students have been filing in and out all morning, handing me their papers and wearing expressions that I can only liken to that of the pilgrims when they gave the pox-infected blankets to the Indians: For you! No, really, it's a gift! No, it won't give you diarrhea, back pain and pustules! Joey hasn't shown up yet, and we're down to the wire.
I take no joy in giving students zeros. I like Joey. I think Joey is cool and on the side of Good. I have no doubt that a heart of gold beats beneath that Bob Marley T-shirt and second-hand blazer.
At 11:59, Joey shows up. He's sweaty and breathing hard. I'm relieved until Joey says, "I, uh, have a problem."
No, Joey! No no no no! Come on, Man, sack Up! Be All You Can Be! Make It Happen! Bring It To the Table! Or some other combination of manly exhortation phrases! Just show me you can rise above your own self-imposed limitations and be the smart guy that I know you are!
"My paper's not quite done yet," Joey says. He's staring at his shoes.
"Joey," I say, "what happened?"
"I procrastinated." He's a senior. He's probably 21. But when he says this, he sounds ashamed, like it's third grade and he forgot his styrofoam model of the solar system for Science Day.
"Well, I'm sorry to hear it. I'm about to pack up and leave."
"I know you don't accept late work --" he starts to say, and I want to stop him right there. If you know this, I think, then shouldn't we be done here?
But he continues: "--but I was wondering if maybe I could email it to you today. I can have it done in like two hours."
Two more hours. That's all he wants. This perfectly nice kid in the goofy hat who's maintained a great attitude in a class that seniors usually hate to take. Who's taken his own lackluster performance in stride with a shrug and a smile all semester, knowing that in the big picture of the universe, school isn't really all that galactically important.
He was never bothered by receiving zeros for past missed work. But if he gets a zero for this final paper, he can't pass the class.
I tell him I'm sorry, but no. Of course. Teachers (and pirates, incidentally) are very strict about deadlines. We have to be. It's not about punishing students who are late, it's about maintaining fairness for the other students who get work in on time. I say this to Joey McFakeName. I explain that it's not about coming down on him -- it's about fairness for everyone. I tell him that I think he's smart, a good writer, a good guy, but if I accepted late work from him, I just couldn't justify it to my other 93 students who worked hard to make the deadline.
As I explain all this, I'm aware of two things: 1) My voice is sounding more and more like a father who tells his son, "I'm not angry, son. I'm just disappointed." 2) Joey's eyes are welling up.
Oh Crappity Crap.
It's hard enough when female students cry over stuff like this. When guys cry, it's even more uncomfortable and awful and awkward and I know there's probably something sexist about why it's worse when it's a guy but I can't help it and it's just BAD.
He stands there for a second and he's about to cry, and I'm sitting in my chair and we're both wishing for vortexes beneath us to open up and swallow us fast. Instead, Joey holds out his hand. He's got a sheet of paper. He voice cracks when he says, "I do have this," and when I take it, he turns and walks out quickly, gone.
I read the sheet, which has just a couple of typed paragraphs. It's a letter to me. It begins, "Dear Mr. Smith, I know that I didn't perform well in your class this semester, and that I continually failed to meet your expectations. But I wanted you to know that I think you're an oustanding teacher, and I can see how much my writing has improved under your instruction. I particularly appreciate how..."
ARRGGGHH. He won't write the final paper, but he'll craft an eloquent, grammatically flawless letter that now makes me feel like the biggest asshole in academia. Damn you, Joey McFakeName.
I'm still not going to let him email me his paper late. But now I have to feel shitty forever.