I'm extremely worried about the rapid death rate of America's grandparents. Mainly, I'm worried that I'm causing their premature deaths singlehandedly.I have evidence. Last week, on the day my students had a major paper due, I received the following email from four different people. This is an amalgam, but they were very, very similar:
"Dear Professor,
I know you are very strict with assignment deadlines and you say that you do not accept excuses and I totally respect that and therefore would never try to do so. However, I just found out that my (Grandmother/Grandfather, Nana/Pop-pop, Gamma/Gampa) unfortunately died from a (heart attack/pulmonary event/liver disease/falling anvil) yesterday and I have to go home and be there for my family since this is a difficult time for all. I hope you understand that as a result of this difficult situation I will be unable to turn my paper in today."
Not one email. Four. In a class of 30 students. The odds of four students from one class losing a grandparent on the same day are approximately *465,283 to 1.
(*Actual figure as computed by my C-3PO ratio adjustment calculator.)
It's clear to me now: when I assign a paper deadline in class, I'm marking my students' grandparents for death. I clearly possess some sort of dark, Voldemortish power that I never even knew about. There's no need for a death panel in this country, with me on the job.
I know what you're thinking. No, Pirate, such a widespread epidemic among the elderly is simply not possible. Do not be naive, Pirate. Your students are "playing you,"as the kids say. They're trying to "sell you real estate," or make you "eat the brownies." They take you for a "moron."
Sure. As excuses go, of course, Dead Grandparent is a pretty smart choice. The fact is, I don't get emails about dead parents or siblings. If students are lying, they're doing so with one careful eye on their own karma. Killing off grandparents is relatively safe.
And what can a teacher do about it? Make the student prove it? You could demand to see some documentation: a death certificate, the program from the funeral, receipts from the estate auction, the hand-knitted afghan that Sweet Nana left behind after she went to her reward... but that makes you the biggest schmuck teacher of all time, right? (I have colleagues who have actually done this, by the way, demand proof when a student alleges that a death in the family kept them from finishing an assignment. I freely admit that I lack the stones to go that far.)
You can flat-out accuse the student of bullshitting. But at some point, someone will be telling the truth about a grandparent's death, and unless you have a heart like a petrified walnut, you don't want to punish that student just because others have set a new low standard in weasel-like lying.
The Dead Grandparent really is a classic ringer. It worked for Johnny Fairplay on Survivor. It worked for Ferris Bueller's girlfriend. Distinguishing truth from bullshit is tough; all a teacher can ultimately do is rely on instinct. (My advice is watch the eyes when the student tells you their story in your office later. Watch for darting pupils. Or sentences that end with question marks: "Yea, my grandma, like, died? So I, um... can't turn in the paper today? Because of how I'm upset and stuff?")
But then again... what if they're all telling the truth? What if my students' grandparents are keeling over and is my fault? What if my enforcement of assignment deadlines is somehow cosmically responsible for the brutal and untimely demises of my students' beloved grandparents? If so, I feel just awful.
The least I can do is let students know at the start of the semester that if they stay in my class, they're likely to lose one if not both grandparents. Maybe I should put an addendum in my syllabus, recommending that students spend some quality time with any elderly relatives the weekend before our major deadlines -- take them on walks, listen to some stories about the Depression, say any heartfelt goodbyes.
Or maybe I'll just take the opportunity on the first day of every semester to do my best impression of John Houseman in The Paper Chase:
"Ladies and gentlemen, look to your immediate left. Now, look to your right. Look at each other. One of you has a grandparent.... WHO WILL DIE IN THE NEXT FOUR MONTHS. Probably on September 28th, November 3rd, or December 9th."
Too much?







